The End of Eden (1996)

Drama about a young man whose return to the Mormon community where he grew up sparks jealousy and rivalry. Erik Eriksen (Rob Estes) is now a successful New York pianist and he returns to his home village expecting a hero's welcome. However, the locals now regard Erik as an outsider and are suspicious of his success. Only his half-brother Jens welcomes him with open arms, but Erik's growing attraction to Jens' fiancée Chel (Jennie Garth) places them on a collision course which can only end in tragedy.